The crowd mills excitedly outside the IMAX, a blur of black shoes, white socks, sparkly gloves, and the occasional flash of scarlet leather. There is only one possible film they could be here for. It arrives, long awaited, heavy with inherent controversy, burdened with representing a man whose fame can arguably be rivalled only by Jesus Christ himself. A man who smashes records, makes fans faint from beyond the grave, and rewrote the principles of gravity.
Michael Jackson.
Michael emulated what the man himself did at every turn. Moonwalking over numerous records, it debuted with a $218.8 million opening weekend, dethroning Queen biopic ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’ as highest grossing musical biopic.
However, the film raises an uncomfortable question of what audiences want from these films, and whether this is what is sold to them. The sanitised events, muddled timelines, and erasure of unsavoury details beg the question of whether audiences are truly seeking biographies or are willing to accept the attempts at resurrection that studios and estates produce.
The musical biopic has become one of Hollywood’s most dependable genres, as icons such as Bob Dylan, Bob Marley, Elton John, and most notably Freddie Mercury and Elvis Presley have returned to the metaphorical stage. Bohemian Rhapsody, Elvis, and now Michael have been especially influential.
These all saw a renewed interest in the music, as according to Billboard Elvis’ Spotify streams surged by 67 % in the US alone, Queen saw their on-demand streams triple, whilst Michael Jackson’s on-demand streams increased by 146%. This is cited as evidence of these films cultural value as younger audiences become inaugurated, and original fans are revitalised.
However, these numbers expose the central issue. Indeed, the trinity share key overlapping features: controversial icons musical geniuses, who happen, conveniently, to be dead, granting filmmakers the freedom to profit off their successes. Stories are sieved through surviving relatives, estates, business partners, bandmates, each with their own interests in preserving legacies, and profiting off legendary musical feats. Their lives are condensed into songs, and everything in between are unskippable ads.
Michael presents this paradox most clearly. Whilst his daughter Paris publicly criticised the film’s ‘full-blown lies’, and his closest siblings kept their distance, Prince Jackson served as an executive producer. Control rested with the Jackson estate and family members whose stewardship of Michael’s image is tied to their own relevance. While Jaafar Jackson was spectacular, his casting reeks of the familiar family-centricity that bolstered the Jackson image. While those individuals continue to eat off his plate, the audience is given the uncanny embodiment of Michael Jackson, finished with creative CGI to fill in for the fans who never got to see him in person. Perhaps this is the whole point.
It seems a strategy of producer Graham King; who’s Bohemian Rhapsody followed a similar pattern. Made with heavy involvement from Brian May and Roger Taylor, Freddie Mercury’s life was minimised into a redemption arc culminating in the infamous Live Aid sequence, confirming the nature of these productions. These productions are less interested in biography than in legacy and sales management, concerned with runoff success, enjoyed by those who remain.
This isn’t necessarily sinister: estates wish to protect reputations while audiences seem happy to dance in the cinema aisles. Yet it is worth asking why the biographical framework is necessary. If the goal is to recreate the artist experience, projects such as ABBA Voyage demonstrated that fans happily engage with digital recreations without the pretence of biography.
Drugs, allegations, abuse, and uncomfortable romances are rearranged, softened, or omitted. The results are visually dazzling, featuring remarkable physical performances, as Butler, Malek and Jackson embodied their respective icons with haunting accuracy. The term ‘biopic’ however is ambitious. These films are mere concerts. Existing to rouse fans, reignite streams, and provide the comforting illusion that we have come to understand our beloved artists a little better. In fact, they tell us more about those left behind, the families, estates and industries who have personal interests in managing cultural memory.
With Michael 2 already in production, Graham King may yet prove otherwise. Unless the genre, however, becomes ready to embrace ugliness and uncertainty the musical biopic and representations of the lives of legends such as Michael Jackson may indeed remain, as MJ himself would say, really really bad.
Sources
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/articles/crl1lpzp4z5o. https://www.billboard.com/pro/elvis-soundtracks-chart-elvis-presley-movie/ https://www.billboard.com/music/music-news/music-biopics-queen-michael-jackson-r-kelly-streaming-gains-8546438/https://www.billboard.com/music/chart-beat/michael-jackson-best-streaming-week-after-michael-movie-1236240552/

Leave a Reply